Evangelical View
Evangelicals generally believe that Jews are indeed God’s chosen people based on biblical scripture. They affirm the covenant made with the Jewish people in the Old Testament, emphasizing the significance of Israel in God’s redemptive plan. Many Evangelicals support the modern state of Israel and view it as a fulfillment of biblical prophecy. Additionally, they believe that while Jews hold a special place in God’s plan, salvation comes through faith in Jesus Christ, which opens the way for all people, including Jews, to connect with God.
Amish View
The Amish perspective tends to be more reserved regarding the notion of Jews as God’s chosen people. While they respect the Jewish heritage and recognize the importance of the Old Testament, their focus is primarily on living a Christ-centered life without emphasizing a specific chosen status for any ethnic group. Amish theology centers around community, humility, and a direct relationship with God, rather than claiming any particular ethnic or national privilege. They hold that all believers, regardless of background, are children of God through faith and obedience to Christ.
Conclusion
Both traditions affirm a deep respect for Jewish identity and heritage but diverge in their theological implications. Evangelicals celebrate a distinct covenant relationship, while the Amish emphasize equal standing in faith, valuing community and personal integrity above ethnic distinctions. Each perspective invites believers to reflect on the themes of divine love, grace, and the universal call to a life devoted to God.
