Apollos: Friends, Romans—well, not Romans, but friends nonetheless—lend me your ears. If time travel were a stage, I would step upon it with a golden tongue and argue for it as the highest of arts: a chance to correct error, to witness truth, to bring the rhetoric of experience to those who have only hearsay. Imagine standing before Socrates and saying, “Sir, your argument might be sharper if you tried Twitter.”—I mean, if you could. Time travel is the ultimate public lecture tour: attend, learn, improve the city.
Balaam: Hearken! Hearken—and bring coin. Time travel, you say? A prophet knows a good thing when it smells like silver. Why travel for truth when one may travel for treasure? See a battle before it begins, place a bet, return with a purse heavy as a harvest. I prophesy profit! If the future is open to the highest bidder, then by my beard I shall be both seer and toll-collector. Tickets for Exodus, anyone?
Apollos: Ah, Balaam, ever the impresario of the improbable! Permit me to respond with clarity: knowledge without wisdom is a noisy gong. To pluck events from their place like figs from a tree risks turning noble lessons into mere curiosities. You propose visiting past triumphs to plunder them for lucre—how vapid. The value of learning is not to be auctioned; it is to refine character. Time travel should be a classroom, not a casino.
Balaam: Character? Nay, Apollos, character will not build you a house nor secure you a stable of donkeys. Besides, why should we be moral when morality is so dreadfully unreliable for turning a profit? Imagine: I send a courier to warn a king of an ambush; the king avoids it, pays me handsomely for the whisper, and history calls it wisdom. Who then will call me greedy? Historians have poor hearing.
Apollos: You fashion ethics as a ledger, Balaam. But tell me—if one were to go back and avert a calamity, would that not increase the sum of human flourishing? Or would it instead unravel the tapestry so that the very thread that taught humility is gone? There is a paradox here, like an echo that answers a question you have not yet asked. The wise time traveler must ask: should we change what made us who we are?
Balaam: Paradoxes are profitable puzzles. If we cannot untie paradoxes, we shall knit them into cloaks and auction them in the market. Besides, consider the fashions one could import: I could go forward, take a look at sandals that do not slip on temple floors, come back, and sell the design. Who cares if a philosopher becomes less melancholic? He will still hire me to arrange his lectures.
Apollos: You treat history as a tailor treats fabric—cutting whatever pleases the eye. But history is not merely clothing for vanity; it is the record of sacrifice, the ledger of lessons. To pluck a single moment is to risk collapsing causes into accidents. And there are other perils: the grandfather paradox, for one. If you travel back and silence your own nascency, who will profit from your cunning then? You cannot buy your own birth certificate with coin.
Balaam: Ha! The grandfather paradox is but a sound that startles timid men. I shall circumvent it easily: I shall never meet my grandfather—only his creditors. I will adjust markets without changing my lineage. And if someone speaks of paradox, I will sell them a paradox-proof warranty with two signatures and my donkey’s hoofprint.
Apollos: Your donkey’s hoofprint will not stop cascading effects. The butterfly effect is subtler than a hoof—more like a gold leaf falling into a storm. A small change, a cough in a courtyard, and entire nations rearrange. Consider the moral responsibility: who are we to play at providence? If a traveller returns having prevented grief for one family but caused exile for another, how shall we tally the books?
Balaam: Ah, responsibility—my favorite bedtime story you tell me for free. I shall hire accountants to tally the books. For every exile caused, there will be a ledger entry, a receipt, and a nice interest-bearing apology note. Besides, who made you the arbiter of providence? You, with your speeches polished like amphorae, would be poor at counting sheep. Give me prophecy and ledgers; I shall be both seer and steward.
Apollos: I do not ask to be arbiter; I ask only for prudence. Suppose time travel were real and mouths of orators could cross epochs. Would you not be tempted to stand in the tomb and speak to silence? To whisper to the wounded—”endure”—or to the corrupt—”repent”? The power would corrupt more readily than wine at a feast. Orators may inspire, Balaam, but the temptation to rewrite rhetoric into fame is strong.
Balaam: Temptation makes good elbow room for commerce. But let us set aside virtue and speak of spectacle. Imagine a tour: “Walk Where Wonders Happened.” See the sea part—not from a distance, mind you—but with a backstage pass. I shall sell you a front-row blessing, an audible miracle with snack vendors. You will claim ethical misgivings; I shall claim profit. The festival will have a prophet-led intermission.
Apollos: A prophet-led intermission, indeed—what an image. Yet spectacle without substance is hollow. I can teach rhetors to speak with humility, to ask not how they might profit from history, but how history might profit them. If time travel allows us to converse with our forebears, let it be for counsel: ask Moses about leadership, ask Deborah about courage, ask the poor about what they truly need. Not for selfies with saints.
Balaam: Selfies, you say? Nay, I shall sell you relics and replicas—the ultimate souvenir: a coin minted in the moment the prophet said a good line. People love relics almost as much as they love saving face with a good story. And if you insist on counsel, I will counsel them—for a fee, naturally. Wisdom has a price; even the best speeches require funders.
Apollos: And even the best funders require conscience. Fine, Balaam—let us compromise as men of debate. If time travel comes, we shall found a school where pupils can learn from the past, led by eloquence and tempered by accountability. Meanwhile you can open a modest stall selling guided reflections—no front-row miracles, no backstage pass to divine acts, and for heaven’s sake, no donkey-hoof warranties.
Balaam: A school, you say? Very well—so long as I am its chair, and there is a toll at the gate. We will call it “The Academy of Timely Investments.” I will teach prophecy and profit; you will teach elocution and ethics. Together—oh, what a spectacle! If time travel exists, we will be ready; if it does not, at least the sign will be profitable.
Apollos: Then let us add a motto: “Use time well.” Yours will be, no doubt, “Pay in advance.”
Balaam: And let the record show: I prefer gold in hand to wisdom in promise. Though, come to think of it—if time travel truly exists, perhaps I’ll go back and convince my younger self to invest in humility. For a modest fee, of course.